After a close fight, many fans argue about the scorecards. If you understand how judges score, the decisions make more sense, even when you disagree with them. Here is how scoring works and why decisions are sometimes disputed.
The ten-point must system
In most professional fights, three judges sit at ringside and score every round. The round's winner gets 10 points, and the loser gets 9 or fewer. A knockdown normally costs a fighter an extra point, so a round with one knockdown is usually 10-8. A round that is truly even can be scored 10-10, though that is rare. The judges add up their totals at the end.
What judges are supposed to look at
- Clean punching. Punches that land cleanly on the head or body.
- Effective aggression. Pressure that is also landing, not just walking forward.
- Ring generalship. Controlling the pace and the space.
- Defense. Making the opponent miss.
Why decisions are disputed
- Close rounds. Many rounds are close, and different judges may score them differently.
- Different views of the same fight. A judge near the ring sees angles and impact differently from a television viewer.
- Style bias. Some judges reward activity, others power or defense.
- Mistakes and bias. Occasionally a scorecard looks wrong. The first fight between Canelo Alvarez and Gennady Golovkin in 2017 ended in a draw, and one judge's card for Canelo was widely criticized. See our GGG profile.
Types of result
A fight can end in a unanimous decision, a split decision, a majority decision, a draw or a technical decision if it is stopped by a cut or accident. Our fight card guide explains each term.
How to score a fight yourself
- Decide who won each round before looking at the commentators' view.
- Score close rounds for the fighter who landed the cleaner punches.
- Note knockdowns.
- Add up your own totals at the end, then compare them with the official cards.
Practicing this will make you a better viewer, and it will teach you to notice defense and ring control. Read about styles that win rounds without knockouts in our articles on Shakur Stevenson and Mayweather.
Can anything change a result later?
Yes, but rarely. Commissions can change results after drug test failures, as happened in the Garcia vs Haney fight, which was changed to a no contest.